10 tips for catching legendary fish in Red Dead Redemption 2 (2024)

If you’re serious about fishing, and want to catch the best fish that Red Dead Redemption 2 has to offer, you’ll need a considerable wealth of knowledge.

From using the correct bait and finding the legendary fishes’ locations, to specific tricks on reeling them in when the blighters start nipping, this fishing tips guide has got you covered.

1. Learn to fish

You aren’t automatically able to fish when you start playing Red Dead Redemption 2, but it won’t be long before you are able to pick up a rod and begin your fishing journey. During Chapter Two, you’ll be given a quest by Abigail Roberts called ‘A Fisher of Men', where you take John Marston’s son, Jack, out for a spot of fishing. Here, you’ll learn the basics, getting to grips with how to cast you rod, reel in your catch and avoid the fish getting away.

2. Learn the basics

It’s very easy to fish in Red Dead Redemption 2. Select the rod from your items, then press L2/LT to hold it with both hands, and press R2/RT and let go to cast your line; the longer you hold R2/RT, the further you cast. While still holding L2/LT, slowly reel in using the Right Analogue stick to attract the fish’s attention, or tap R2/RT to flick the rod.

When you feel a nip, the controller will vibrate slightly. Once the fish has completely bitten the hook, press R2/RT straight away. When the controller isn’t vibrating and the fish isn’t trying to get away, reel it in by rotating the right analogue stick. If it begins to vibrate, stop straight away and control the fish with the left analogue, moving it left or right. Once the fish calms down again, reel it back in. Follow this simple pattern to catch a fish, but be prepared for a struggle when it comes to the legendary fish.

3. How to hunt for legends

Legendary fish won’t be available as soon as you learn to fish. You have to find a brilliantly named stranger called Jeremy Gill, who is located on a short pier along the northeast shoreline of Flat Iron Lake. He’ll give you the quest ‘Fisher of Fish,’ which includes a map of every location of each of the 13 legendary fish. While it’s not the best of maps – each location isn’t labelled – it shouldn’t take long to work out exactly where they are. For your reference, the locations are:

Once you’ve caught each fish, make sure you post them straight to Jeremy Gill or else it won’t be marked off on the quest.

Related

How to win a duel in Red Dead Redemption 24 min readRead Story

4. You need a special kind of bait

To be able to catch the legendary fish, you won’t simply be able to use any old bait. There are three types of special bait/lures that you can purchase for $20 each in Lagras. Each one is specific to a type of water; the special river lure, special lake lure, and special swamp lure. Once you’ve purchased the lures, they can be reused for every fish, so you’ll only ever need to buy them once.

See Also
Lion

5. Use the lures correctly

It’s worth noting that you’re more likely to catch the legendary fish if you’re using the correct lure in the correct place. A special river lure is going to be less effective if you’re using it in the Bayous of Lagras, purely because it's a much swampier area. Likewise, using a special swamp lure to catch the Lake Sturgeon isn’t going to work. Assess the type of water for the environment, and go from there.

6. Watch out for the notice

Whenever you enter the correct area on the map for the fish you’re trying to catch, a notification will pop up in the top-left corner of the screen alerting you to the fact you’re in the right place for a new legendary fish. This can be incredibly helpful because if you think you’re in the correct area, but haven’t had the notification, it probably that means you’re not where you need to be.

Related

Here are 5 tips for starting Red Dead Redemption 26 min read
How to bag yourself Legendary Animals in Red Dead …8 min read

7. Patience is a virtue

Fishing for legendary fish can take much more time than normal, and it’s important to stay patient. If you've spent five minutes in one area and nothing has happened, draw the line back and move to a different spot. As long as it’s within the correct area, you’ll be fine. There’s a lot of movement in the water to let you know that there are fish available, so pay attention to the bubbles that appear on the surface. Improve your chances by casting your line right into the centre of a few of them.

8. Advanced techniques

You’ll find the legendary fish are much harder to catch, so knowing a couple of extra techniques really helps to draw them in a bit faster. During the reeling in stage, pull back on the left analogue stick to draw them in a bit faster. Also, when the fish is resisting, click the Right Analogue stick to cause it to stop temporarily. Using both of these techniques as well as what you already know will make it easier to land one of those legendary fishes.

9. Watch the wave

Usually, if the legendary fish is near, you’ll see a big wave of movement within the water. Keep an eye out for them, then once the wave comes to a standstill, cast your line into the place where it stopped. Bigger fish tend to affect the water’s movement, so being alert to these waves can help to locate the fishes you want to catch.

10. The early bird catches the worm

A lot of fish tend to disappear in the night-time, so it’s always best to start bright and breezy at dawn. Camp out and wait for it to get light, as more fish will be swimming about when the sunlight cracks through the clouds.

Related

How to get rich quick in Red Dead Redemption 27 min readRead Story

For more gaming coverage, follow @RedBullGames on Twitter and Instagram and like us on Facebook

10 tips for catching legendary fish in Red Dead Redemption 2 (2024)

FAQs

10 tips for catching legendary fish in Red Dead Redemption 2? ›

Best way to catch Legendary Fish

To do this, you'll need to use the 'advanced reeling-in technique'. So when a Legendary Fish is tired and no longer thrashing in the water, tilt the left analog stick back to pull your rod up, then quickly reel in with the right analog stick (spin the stick clockwise).

Is there a trick to catching legendary fish in RDR2? ›

Best way to catch Legendary Fish

To do this, you'll need to use the 'advanced reeling-in technique'. So when a Legendary Fish is tired and no longer thrashing in the water, tilt the left analog stick back to pull your rod up, then quickly reel in with the right analog stick (spin the stick clockwise).

What is the easiest legendary fish to catch in RDR2? ›

The Legendary Smallmouth Bass is one of the easiest to get to. It's in lake Owanjila just to the west of Strawberry. Use the Special Lake Lure to catch it.

What bait to use to catch legendary fish in RDR2? ›

But, before you do anything, head to Lagras just south of Bluewater Marsh and buy these three items: Special Lake Lure, Special River Lure, Special Swamp Lure. These lures are $20 each but basically fit the purpose for this quest, and you'll struggle to get a bite without them.

What attracts big fish in RDR2? ›

You can purchase basic bait types like bread, corn, and cheese, or spend more money on worms and crayfish that help you land bigger fish. There are also lures specific to rivers, lakes, and swamps, as well as "special" lures that you'll need to catch the biggest fish and the Legendary ones.

What is the hardest fish to catch in RDR2? ›

The legendary bullhead catfish may not be the largest, but it's still the toughest catch.

How many legendary fish can Arthur catch? ›

There are a total of thirteen legendary fish in RDR2. Each of these fish are larger and rarer than their non-legendary counterparts. Players will have to catch each of these fish to complete the "A Fisher of Fish" quest. To start the quest, people will need to speak with Jeremy Gill.

What is the hardest legendary animal to find in rdr2? ›

Since the Legendary Bharati Grizzly Bear is a tough foe requiring numerous shots to take it down, it is considered the most difficult legendary animal to hunt in Red Dead Redemption 2. After hunting this fascinating creature, you can take it to the trapper who will allow you to purchase a Legendary Bear Head Hat.

What is the rarest fish in RDO? ›

The Muskie is the most elusive fish on this list. It loves the icy cold water of West Elizabeth, Ambarino and New Hanover. The best places to track down this beast are on the Owanjila west of Strawberry, Lake Isabella, and in the northern part of the Kamassa River near Brandywine Drop.

Can you wild bait for legendary fish? ›

Using Wild Bait with your fishing rod reduces the delay before a nibble by 62.5%. There is also a chance to catch two fish, equal to 0.25 + Daily Luck / 2.0. The chance to catch 2 fish does not apply to Legendary Fish.

Why is Elysian Pool poisoned? ›

The Elysian Pool is contaminated by toxic runoff from an abandoned mining operation nearby. Behind the waterfall is a sprawling cave system containing an underground stream of polluted, yellow water which drains into the pool.

Where can I get legendary lures? ›

To be able to catch the legendary fish, you won't simply be able to use any old bait. There are three types of special bait/lures that you can purchase for $20 each in Lagras. Each one is specific to a type of water; the special river lure, special lake lure, and special swamp lure.

Is it better to cook or sell fish RDR2? ›

the difference in price between raw & cooked is not big, but the benefit of the cooking is the fish can now be stored way more easily & because of that then sold to either Johnny in bulk or Ted Selly if you meet him.

Where can you catch the biggest fish in Red Dead Redemption 2? ›

To catch bigger fish, players can also go to deeper parts of water. For that, players can either hijack a boat or upgrade the camp and take the camp's canoe out.

How do you keep or release legendary fish in rdr2? ›

Once you've caught a Legendary Fish, store it on your horse and immediately head to the nearest post office. Keeping the catch on your horse, you can mail it to Jeremy Gill. After 24 hours, you'll receive your reward for you fish.

Why can't you catch the legendary Catfish rdr2? ›

Reports suggest that this fish prefers overcast weather. The size of this Legendary Catfish could be over ninety inches long and weighing around one-hundred and eighty pounds, which might be why this catfish has never been, and may never be, caught.

Why are fish hard to reel in? ›

Because bigger fish pull harder, reeling in a big fish is often a challenge for most anglers, including experienced pros. The first sign that you've hooked a big one is the sound the reel makes when it speeds into reverse, taking line off your fishing reel while you are holding it tightly.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner

Last Updated:

Views: 5834

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner

Birthday: 1994-06-25

Address: Suite 153 582 Lubowitz Walks, Port Alfredoborough, IN 72879-2838

Phone: +128413562823324

Job: IT Strategist

Hobby: Video gaming, Basketball, Web surfing, Book restoration, Jogging, Shooting, Fishing

Introduction: My name is Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner, I am a zany, graceful, talented, witty, determined, shiny, enchanting person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.